project 151

Woman-founded, youth-led, pro-life organisation

Not all choices are the same

One of the arguments made by the pro-abortion supporters is that an abortion – the intentional ending of a human life in the womb – is the same as a refusing blood to someone in need of a transfusion. Indeed, these actions are both choices. However, not all choices are the same in their nature nor in their consequences.

For example, if I am hungry and I choose to eat an apple over some cake, this is a choice that I make. The consequences are different, depending on what I choose to eat, for my body’s health. This choice is informed an instinct of the body to nourish itself in order not to perish. It does involve the intellect, by which we understand things, as well as the free will, by which we choose a course of action, and the conscience which morally directs or encourages the will towards the better choice. 

The will, being free, can reject both the understanding derived from the intellect and the moral encouragement of our conscience. However, if I choose contrary to both or either the understanding or the moral voice which guide my will, the choice does not invalidate either of them, nor does it make the choice wise or good: it is still a stupid and evil choice.

What are the consequences of this type of choice? They are limited to me – for the most part. It is tempting to argue that certain choices impact only us but, in reality, they impact others too, to various degrees. For example, eating the cake might not be good for my health and, if I have people who depend on me, this will impact them. Nevertheless, for the sake of the argument, let us say that this choice, to eat cake or apple when hungry, produces consequences which I alone bear.

In the case of abortion, there is no basic instinct involved in killing the unborn child. In fact, it goes against such an instinct, to kill the baby in the womb, which is the maternal instinct of caring for and protecting the child. In the case of a blood transfusion, there is a basic instinct involved, that of helping another human being in need – for we are all social in nature.

Take now the example of another choice, that of going to war. The same elements are involved in making this choice, as well as the one above: the intellect, the free will, and the conscience. Yet, the consequences are different than in the first example, and the moral dimension of our choices is far more visible. Going to war can be rooted in political reasons, ideological motives, economic interests, or military goals, as well as on base instincts. History is full of examples of conflicts started because of hunger (the instinct to feed) or due to a leader’s desired or not spouse (the instinct to procreate). 

However, the outcomes of such a choice are immense suffering, death, destruction, economic hardship, alienation, and the list of horrible consequences can continue. War impacts many people, perhaps even everyone. Clearly, the choice to go to war is not the same as the choice to eat cake or not. Still, both of them are choices.

Finally, contrast the above two examples with a third one: the choice to rape. In this case, as in the first example, the choice includes a basic instinct, that of sex. However, the aggressor chooses to act on his or her instinct, but the victim does not. The outcome is the violation of another human person potentially for the rest of their lives. Still, here too, a choice was made. Upon what? Upon the view that the victim is not a human person, but an object with which to satisfy an urge.

As such, not all choices are the same in their nature nor in their consequences. Each choice has a moral dimension that depends in its gravity and broadness on the impact that the choice has on others, as well as on ourselves. The pro-abortion ideologues want you to believe that choosing to eat some stake is the same as choosing to murder an unborn child – they are both choices, aren’t they? Yes, they are, but not in the same manner are they choices, nor with the same consequences.

Moreover, there is a difference between not helping someone who needs help (the person needing a blood transfusion) and murdering someone who needs help (an unborn child in the womb). For the pro-abortion supporters, this difference does not exist. The authority to kill an unborn child rest solely, they argue – directly or indirectly – with the person making the choice to have an abortion. 

If authority of action rests solely in one’s choice, then they have defended all the rapes and murders, all the slavery and abuse that has ever existed because these atrocities were committed by people who, too, believed that authority to do something rests solely in their own choices! A rapist chooses to see the victim not as a person, but as something less – an object, for example, and so do murderers, enslavers, and so on. Pro-abortionists sit in the same camp.

Pro-abortion ideologues make a choice to see unborn children not as persons but as something less than a person. As such, they claim, that, because of this choice, they have the right to kill them. Upon this choice – to not acknowledge the personhood of unborn children and, consequently, their rights – rests the entire pro-abortion movement.

Hopefully, one day, they will realise that life is worth defending from its conception to its natural end, with all its beautiful and joyful moments, as well as with its sorrows and sufferings.

By

—

Leave a Reply