project 151

Woman-founded, youth-led, pro-life organisation

Can the law decide who is a person and who is not?

One of the common arguments that the pro-abortion ideologues make is that a foetus is not a person. They offer a range of beliefs for this, including that it is a clump of cells, that it has no consciousness, that it is not self-aware, that it is an “it” not a “he” or a “she”, that the law says so, and the list can go on.

In other words, depending on who you ask, personhood – i.e. that which makes a human being a person, rather than a beast or an object – is rooted in an entirely subjective answer. As such, what is a person is a matter of opinion. 

The issue with this seemingly liberating intellectual position, if it can be called as such, is that if I do not consider you a person, and I give you as “reason” whatever I wish from the above non-exhaustive list of opinions, then, you ought not to be a person. As a result, you should be treated as those beings which are not people: animals, plants, or objects. In fact, pro-abortion supporters treat unborn children as animals at best (calling them parasites) or as objects at worst (calling them “pregnancies”).

In this article, we examine what personhood is, what is a person, the relationship between the law and what a person is, and why a foetus is a person who deserves love and care.

What personhood is – and what it is not

Nowadays, there is an ideological epidemic that pushes people, especially the young, to identify their entire personhood – who they are – with one or two aspects of culture. Identifying oneself with a place, with a set of ideas, with particular artists, with one’s sexuality, is not new nor wrong if it is done appropriately, i.e. with an awareness that a man or a woman is more than that particular aspect of their personhood. Nobody is just this or that: British, black, gay, and so on.

Moreover, personhood is not personality. The latter is concerned more with character and psychological development while the former encompasses personality and much more. If personhood would simply be synonymous with personality, then a person would be only a mind, which, evidently is not true.

Personhood is not one dimensional. As such, one’s personhood is not just psychological, nor only physiological, nor solely spiritual. Rather, one’s personhood is a complex whole made of different parts – some are spiritual, some are psychological, some are physical, some are even cultural, and some are metaphysical. In other words, personhood is the totality of what makes a human being a person.

For example, I am not just my body, nor am I solely my thoughts, nor am I only my cultural background, nor am I just my faith. Today, however, it is easy to find people who “identify” as such and such, reducing the entirety of who they are, at least in their mind, to that aspect. This ideological crisis has been fostered by the entertainment industry, at least in part, and by the technology sector with its developments in social media platforms that have created cult-like bubbles. 

There are people who, unfortunately, identify so strongly with a set of ideas, or with a singer or actor, or with a music genre, and so on, that they seek – consciously or not – to reduce most, if not, all of their personhood to that tiny aspect of reality. 

However, these individuals are often sad or depressed, lonely and unfulfilled. They feel that something is missing, they sense that their being is being reduced to something less than who they are. Indeed, to try to reduce one’s entire personhood to just one thing is to inflict a grave wound upon one’s soul that takes considerable help and time to heal. These individuals need assistance to see that they are complex and not one dimensional, that their personhood is more than just their preference for that type of literature or their sexual orientation or their political views.

But where do all these profound and complex aspects of one’s personhood come? In other words, what makes a human being a person? Can a dog or a tree or a pencil have personhood as well? After all, animals, plants, and objects are also complex beings. Is complexity the root of personhood or is there something else?

What makes a human being a person

The question what a person is, or what is the source of personhood, is very old. Throughout the centuries many thinkers, some religious and some not, have tried to answer it. They came up with a variety of answers. 

Some thought that a person is an animal – rational or political, or both, as Aristotle argued, but an animal nevertheless. With this definition, Darwin and today’s evolutionists also agree. The issue with this definition is that the body and its instincts cannot account for the soul – or, if you reject the existence of a soul, they cannot account for love which is not rational nor instinctual nor chemical.

Others argued that a person is a “rational substance”, such as Boethius. This view confines the personhood to the spiritual realm. In this category we also have the father of existentialist philosophy, Kierkegaard for whom the human being is spirit. However, what about the body? Surely, a definition of what a person is must account for both the material and the spiritual aspect of the human being.

There are other definitions, views, and arguments about what a person is. However, all – if they are subjected to rigorous examination – fall short of one aspect or another of what living as human beings, suffering, thinking, dreaming, loving, and dying tell us about personhood. Dostoevsky came closest to the true (most complete and unchanging across ages) definition of a person when he called the human being a “mystery”.

A mystery is not something about which nothing can be said or known. Rather, it is something about which not everything can be said or known. As such, Dostoevsky’s definition is not obscure but points towards the fact that we, ourselves, cannot reach on our own a complete, all-encompassing definition of what a person is. Why is that?

To define what a person is, one must know – exactly, without doubt, with total and undoubting certainty – when life begins.

Nowadays, there are many theories and views about when human life begins. Some say life begins at this point or that point after conception. Language such as “clump of cells”, “pregnancy tissue”, or simply “pregnancy”, instead of the simple but correct word, child, suggests the efforts made by pro-abortion ideologues to justify killing unborn children by choosing, themselves, when human life begins. They argue that science is on their side. Science is not on their side, and the evidence is overwhelming. More importantly, however, this is not a scientific matter – it is at least metaphysical but, in truth, it is theological. Those who bring science into this matter denigrate scientific efforts with ideology and a political agenda that has the primary focus the murder of unborn children.

Life’s genesis has only one and the same starting point for each human being. My life started exactly at the same point as yours, although, maybe not at the same time. If we are to put our finger on a moment in time, it is at conception: no later, no earlier. This is true both biologically and metaphysically. 

However, if one is to assent that there is a God and that this God is the One revealed to us by the Bible and professed by the Holy Catholic Church, then human life, although it has a firm beginning in time at the moment of conception, has always existed, in some form of divine thought, in the bosom of the Eternal Father.

This perspective not only enriches the notion of what a person is, but it also brings clarity to it. For, if we accept the Bible, we learn that all of us, young and old, men and women, have the same value – and therefore, ought to have the same rights – because we are all made in the “image and likeness” of God (cf. Gen 1:26-27). Personhood is rooted in this truth: that each one of us is created by God in His own “image and likeness”.

A few words on the law

Following the train of thought from the previous section of this article, we can observe that the words of God are a law in themselves. They are the authority upon which a human being’s personhood and its immutable and unchanging dignity rests. This is the objective moral position when it comes to the value of human life, irrespective of what one thinks, feels, experiences, or imagines.

However, this is not the same law that pro-abortion ideologues mean when they proclaim that an unborn child is not a person because the law say so, because quite clearly, the divine law, i.e. the words of God, state the opposite. Rather, they refer to man-made laws. So, what are these laws?

Laws are written or unwritten rules that govern individuals and communities, larger or smaller. Several questions immediately arise: 

Who makes these rules? Why do people follow them? Does everyone have to follow them for these rules to be considered law or just some people from some place? Do they have to be followed by all people at all time, across the ages? Are there different types of law, e.g. moral, natural, political etc.? What happens if one does not follow them? Is there punishment? If yes, who enforces these rules and ensures that there is punishment for not following them?

All of the above questions concern what law is. They are not easy to be answered and, when they are answered, their answers can never be exact. The idea of law is too big and complex for a single definition to encompass it. This is why we have concepts such as “the moral law”, or “the natural law”, or “the law of the land”, and so on. 

That there is a moral law we have as proof our conscience. That there is a natural law we have as proof that there is proper order in nature and society, even if in the latter the form of this order may differ, its existence is obvious. Finally, that there is a law of the land we have as proof the government – again, in whatever form it may be.

Nowadays, the concept of law that prevails in Western society is a set of rules backed by the government. Moreover, the institution of government, as well as the act of governing and the idea of such authority are primarily moral rather than political. However, the relationship between morality and law is murky in our society. 

Many people seem to think that what is moral is strictly a matter of private judgment, i.e. of opinion or of personal taste. That morality is not a matter of opinion or of any subjective preference is clear by the fact that to kill, to rape, to violate, to steal, to torture, to lie, and so on, are wrongs no matter the culture, time, or place.

That some people do these things does not make them right. That most people can do these things does not make them right. That all people are capable of doing these things, fortunately, does not make them right. In the Christian tradition, this is known as the doctrine of the original sin. This doctrine explains why we are all flawed and inclined to do bad things, be these things big or small, and why, at the same time, we know – through a sort of intuition that we call conscience – that what we have done is wrong. 

Consequently, every woman who has an abortion knows that she has done something wrong, for it is murder, or every man who encourages or forces a woman to have an abortion knows that what he has done is wrong, for he encouraged or forced murder.

However, in order to justify the wrong done, pro-abortion ideologues would work backwards from the murder (the abortion) and construct quasi-philosophical or quasi-scientific arguments to serve as an explanation for why killing an unborn child is not wrong, but right. This perspective they want reflected in the law. Those in the pro-abortion movement want the choice to kill an unborn child not only to be sanctioned by the power of the government but also to be morally good because they say, think, imagine so.

Again, this view of reality they want enshrined in the law of the land, which is the type of law that the majority of pro-abortion campaigners recognise as “the law”. Therefore, when they say that a foetus is not a person because the law says so, what they are saying is that an unborn child in his or her mother’s womb is not a person by the authority of the current government and, so they hope, of future governments too.

However, we have already seen that the authority which gives dignity to all men and women, unborn or alive – even to the dead – comes not from the government, but from the divine law of the Creator who made human beings in His own “image and likeness”. This is the true – and only – authority that gives and sustains the value of each individual person, across time and space.

When the law decides who is and who is not to be treated as a person

If we acknowledge, as we should, that the question of whether or not an unborn child is a person is a moral and theological question then we can seek where does the authority which decides all personhood rests. 

The position, which pro-abortion ideologues take, that this authority is with the government, is the same position that the Communists and Nazis – and every other group of people in history who wanted a certain part of the population to be less than human – took. The government has no authority to decide or alter reality, nor any power to do so. 

Unfortunately, the ideological position of the Nazis, for example, who wanted the Jews to be viewed as non-human and passed laws towards that aim, is still fully alive today, fuelling the pro-abortion movement. Because of their efforts, unborn children are killed in their mother’s wombs or experimented on. This is sanctioned by the law of the land, i.e. by the rules made by the government.

In part, the reason for why the law of the land cannot be the authority which decides who is a person and who is not is because it changes with different governments. However, the dignity that belongs to each person and their value does not change.

If it be granted that who is a person and who is not is to be decided by government-backed laws, then on what authority are they made? Of the government? Any kind of government? What gives the government this authority? The people? Then what gives the people this authority? 

The people are individuals: one, and another one, and yet another one, and so on. Therefore, is the argument that if enough individuals come together and pronounce that certain human beings are not persons then they should be viewed and treated as such? The pro-abortion ideologues, like the Nazis and the communists and any group in history that has taken up this dark banner of hate and sin, reply yes. Sitting alongside all these atrocious groups, in the name of some goal – healthcare, medical care, rights etc. – pro-abortionists point the finger at unborn children and say: “You are not persons!”

The sad reality is that these babies are no less human beings and, therefore, no less persons than anyone alive today. They were all made in the “image and likeness” of God, just as those who advocate, encourage, or indeed, execute their killing were also made. The act of creation is not bound to nor can it be restricted by the law. No matter how much the Nazis argued that the Jews were not persons, the Jews were still persons. No matter how much the pro-abortion ideologues argue that unborn children are not persons, they are still persons.

Is a foetus a person?

We are already in the midst of the greatest genocide ever recorded. Children are killed, in their mother’s wombs, in the millions each year. These unborn babies are still persons, no matter what the law says.

The word “foetus” is the Medieval spelling of the original Latin word “fētus” which means offspring. Is, therefore, a human offspring a child? This, indeed, is the ridiculous and tragic question which the pro-abortion advocates are asking – and they are doing so with much seriousness. 

To answer it once and for all: Yes, a human offspring is a child. Of course, those who want to kill children in the womb know this. What they really want is for them to decide when life begins (as if it can begin at any point later than at conception) and for their criminal desire to be enshrined in the law.

However, we have seen that the law is not the source of what makes a human being a person or not – rather, it is God’s act of creation. When the government gets involved in matters that are above its authority, such as legislating who is or is not to be treated as a person, irrespective of the undeniable reality that they are a person, all sorts of atrocities ensue.

The law cannot eradicate personhood, which is given by God. It can encourage, allow, or defend treating others as less than persons, however, as we have seen above in the case of the Nazis and other such groups. In fact, it was because of what the Nazis did that there are now international human rights, which, above all, include the right to life. Every human being, i.e. every person, has the right to life, including unborn children.

Conclusion

In this article we looked at the claim that a foetus is not a person by virtue of a law. We examined firstly what personhood is – so that it cannot be claimed that because a foetus does not have this or that (personality, awareness, knowledge, whatever) means that he or she is not a person. 

We then looked at the source of one’s personhood, i.e. at what makes a person. Here we saw that it is God’s act of creation in his “image and likeness” that makes human beings persons. He, the Creator, gives the same immutable dignity to all men and women, old and young, born and unborn – and even to those that have passed away.

Afterwards, we took a look at what the law is and what the pro-abortionists mean by the law. Furthermore, we saw that when the government’s laws (which is the type of law that those in the pro-abortion movement acknowledge as valid) decide who is to be treated as a person and who is not what happens: murders, genocides, and other atrocities.

Finally, we argued that a foetus, by virtue of being a human offspring – human beings being persons – he or she is a child, i.e. a person too, deserving the same treatment as any other human person.

By

—

Leave a Reply